A visit to Johannesburg in the early 1990s shows how a small team conquered the motor insurance market with telephone sales and clever pricing logic, long before Europe was talking about direct insurance. A story about distribution systems, margins and the human core of entrepreneurial success.
At the beginning of the 1990s, Paul, then a board member of an innovative insurance company in Argentina, traveled to South Africa. A friend had told him about a company in Johannesburg that had gained an astonishingly large market share with unusual marketing and sales methods. The young company president’s invitation not only took him to the company, but also to his private home, an estate surrounded by a well-tended garden with jacaranda and fruit trees, African art and a palpable sense of wealth.
The next day, he visits the head office. On the way to the upper floor, he notices that something is fundamentally different here than in European insurance companies at the time: large rooms full of employees who are constantly on the phone. Insurance is actively sold. Not through intermediaries, but directly.
The president is barely older than his team. Four young colleagues surround him, curious about the visitor from Argentina who wants to know how they were able to win a significant share of the motor insurance market in a short space of time.
Sales as the actual innovation
During the conversation, it becomes clear that the revolution is not in the product, but in the process. The Group has systematically developed telephone sales, trained employees in a targeted manner and standardized call processes. Insurance is no longer seen as a consulting-intensive individual decision, but as a scalable act of purchase.
This was almost unimaginable for the European industry at the time. The customer traditionally came via the broker or agent. Here, however, the insurer sought the customer itself, in a structured, predictable manner and in large numbers.
The engine of expansion was therefore not a better tariff or a new type of cover, but an industrial organization of distribution.
Price psychology instead of price wars
The tariff policy seems even more remarkable to Paul. The president explains to him that premiums should not be reduced to such an extent that only minimal profits remain. The discount just has to be big enough to trigger the impulse to switch.
In doing so, the company contradicted a reflex that is still widespread today: buying market share through maximum price reduction. Instead, it opted for a precisely calculated difference that is sufficiently attractive for the customer and at the same time highly profitable for the insurer.
The strategy was not aimed at mathematical undercutting, but at human decision-making behavior. The impressive villa in which Paul lived was, to a certain extent, the visible expression of this margin.
The market is created in the mind of the customer
The method transformed motor insurance into a standardized consumer good. The focus was not on trust or long-term advice, but on the moment of decision. The customer was given a clear incentive to simply switch without the insurer having to sacrifice its profitability.
Looking back, it seems like an early direct insurance model at a time when the term didn’t even exist. The real disruption consisted of understanding the customer’s behavior and building a reproducible system on this basis.
An unexpected personal touch
As they say goodbye, the president’s wife tells a final story. The room where Paul had spent the night had previously been used by Nelson Mandela, shortly after his release from prison on Robben Island. The successful entrepreneur not only had a business instinct, but also a social attitude.
Conclusion
This episode shows that upheavals in the insurance industry rarely start with technology. They arise from a new look at sales, pricing and decision-making psychology. The young entrepreneur in Johannesburg did not change policy conditions, he changed the way people buy insurance. And that was the real revolution.
Binci Heeb
Paul the Insurer has other content that may interest you, such as the series of interviews with insurance industry executives.
Read also: Insurance for high-risk jobs: an idea from São Paulo
Search:
Sponsors:
